http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-3641696/Why-Barclays-letting-pushy-salesmen-flog-100-diet-pills-branches-owned-firms-hijack-community-programme.html
Why IS Barclays letting pushy salesmen flog £100 diet pills in its branches?
US-owned firms hijack community programme
- Salesmen from controversial health schemes setting up stalls in branches
- Most of the firms involved are US-owned and known for pushy sales tactics
- Barclays set up its scheme allowing small businesses to operate pop-up stands in its branches in 2014
Salesmen from controversial health schemes are setting up stalls in Barclays branches and pouncing on people waiting to be served.
Customers are being flogged expensive face creams and diet pills — and asked to become part-time sales staff themselves.
Most of the companies involved are U.S.-owned and notorious for pushy sales tactics.
They have hijacked a Barclays community programme that was designed to give small local businesses a cost-free way of reaching High Street shoppers.
Shopfront: Salesmen from controversial health schemes are setting up stalls in Barclays branches and pouncing on people waiting to be served
The revelation has sparked concern that elderly customers who depend on branches are at risk of being targeted.
Witnesses say salesmen are telling elderly customers that the products, which include £100 diet pills, energy bars and £30 herb-infused face creams, can ease ailments such as arthritis.
Stay-at-home mothers are being told they can make an 'easy' £300 a month if they sign up to become saleswomen.
Yet most of those lured in will be unaware of the dubious health benefits of the products. And those recruited as agents can face enormous pressure to sell — and stinging costs if they fail to hit monthly targets.
Forever Living, Arbonne and Herbalife all appear to be regular fixtures in Barclays branches. They are dubbed 'multi-level marketing schemes' because they work by signing up customers to flog expensive cosmetics or health products to friends, family and neighbours.
Typically, recruits work as and when they want — as they're technically self-employed — to supplement household income. Often they're promised promotions and extra cash if they regularly sign up new sellers.
Pushy: Most of the companies involved are U.S.-owned and notorious for their sales tactics
Critics have accused the companies of having a similar selling style to pyramid schemes — illegal businesses that promise staff rewards for enrolling others, as opposed to offering income for selling products.
Mick McAteer, founder of consumer rights organisation the Financial Inclusion Centre, says: 'It seems a real shame for Barclays' efforts to help entrepreneurs to be ruined by a failure to make the proper checks on the firms allowed to sell to customers.'
Barclays set up its scheme allowing small businesses to operate pop-up stands in its branches in 2014. You can apply to a local branch to put up a stall and the bank makes no money from the arrangement.
However, Money Mail has discovered that instead of helping local entrepreneurs, the spaces have been seized on by big overseas businesses.
Representatives of Forever Living have been spotted in Barclays in Horley, Redhill, York, Stafford and Leominster.
The Arizona-based firm, which raked in £120 million in Britain last year, sells beauty products and health foods containing aloe vera or beeswax. Items offered in Barclays include a £109 nine-day diet kit.
The firm's 40,000 UK sales reps, known as Forever Business Owners, are charged £199.75 for a box of products when they sign up.
Recruits say they're encouraged by senior distributors to push items on Facebook and lure in friends as it can be costly if they fail to meet monthly targets.
Laura Jones, 39, a former distributor in the North-West, was left £1,000 out of pocket after six months working for Forever Living.
The new mother, who'd been suffering post-natal depression, was introduced to the company by a friend. She says she was told she could earn £300 a month for five hours' work a week. But she was unable to sell enough.
She says she was forced to buy the products herself to meet her manager's expectations. She says she was also told to target new mothers and online forums. Forever Living says it does not enforce sales targets.
Laura says: 'There is no way Barclays should allow Forever Living into the branch to sell. It offers a dream to the vulnerable, which turns out to be smoke and mirrors.'
Callous: The firms have hijacked a Barclays community programme that was designed to give small local businesses a cost-free way of reaching High Street shoppers
Forever Living was criticised by the Advertising Standards Authority watchdog last year for false claims about the health benefits of its products.
Herbalife sales staff put up huge signs in branches offering 'extra cash and flexible hours' to those who sign up. A sales rep who claims to tout regularly for cosmetics firm Arbonne in Barclays says long bank queues make it easy to sell.
'I'm like the entertainment to the customers waiting — a bit like in Disneyland,' the woman, who asked not to be named, told Money Mail.
Arbonne reps are also encouraged to recruit more staff — called in jargon 'growing their downline'. Distributors in banks are offering a pot of face cream, which is listed at £30 online, and face powder at £31.
We found examples of Herbalife stalls in Kendal, Leamington Spa and Richmond, North Yorkshire. Salesmen for the Los Angeles-based firm, whose sales increased by $12.6 million (£8.9 million) in Britain in 2014, were flogging jars of chocolate weight-loss powder costing £28.40 online.
U.S. watchdog the Federal Trade Commission is investigating allegations that — in the style of pyramid selling — Herbalife's profits come mainly from signing up more distributors, rather than product sales.
The firm says distributors are not rewarded purely for recruiting staff but receive a royalty from any products these recruits sell.
Furious Barclays customers have bombarded the bank's Twitter page demanding it bans the firms. Amy Ip, from London, wrote: 'Why is there a Forever Living stand in your Camberwell branch?'
A contributor to website Mumsnet overheard a Forever Living seller in Barclays telling an elderly man that its aloe vera gel could help his arthritis.
She says: 'It's inappropriate. It gave the impression that the bank approves and endorses this scheme.'
A spokesman for Timeless Vie, which campaigns against multi-level marketing company recruitment, says: 'Barclays has a duty of financial care towards its customers and discovering they are allowing these companies space in their branches is deeply troubling.'
A Barclays spokesman says: 'Clearly, in these examples raised by Money Mail, the companies have not met our guidelines. Following a review, we will now be prioritising the scheme for local community groups to ensure they continue to benefit from the free space in branches.'
A Forever Living spokesman says the firm is not a pyramid scheme and is legal. It says it 'rewards endeavour' but those who do not thrive can leave and get their money back.
Gavin Aley, senior director for Herbalife in the UK, says: 'Herbalife has been trading in the UK for 33 years, which has helped customers to maintain a healthy lifestyle.'
An Arbonne spokesman says: 'A pyramid scheme is illegal and Arbonne does not operate such a scheme.'
Ruth Lythe (copyright Daily Mail 2016)
As MLM press articles go David this is as good as it gets, but your articles are a million x more informative.
ReplyDeleteThanks Anonymous, but unfortunately, being more-informed (and informative) than the mainstream media is not difficult. The 'MLM' fairy story began infecting the UK in the early 1970s, so the Daily Mail is a bit late at the scene of the crime.
DeleteI suppose 'better late than never.'
i dont know, David. it seems from Barclays public statement they are already invoking the bad actor defense...
ReplyDelete"Clearly, in these examples raised by Money Mail, the companies have not met our guidelines. Following a review, we will now be prioritising the scheme for local community groups to ensure they continue to benefit from the free space in branches.'"
Presumably they are ok with these criminals setting up booths and being there, and take issue only with the handful of explicit incidents that have made their way out in public. its a PR position, not anything rooted in principle unfortunately
you and I both know that a fraud is committed by the nature of the structure. so they have already missed this truth by allowing the booths to exist on their property.
ShakeOilSalesman - The words 'Bank' and 'morality' have become mutually exclusive. Of course, the name 'Barclays' has been linked with 'Herbalife' in the USA via an amoral stock market analyst, Meredith Adler, who has consistently advised people to buy into the effectively valueless 'Herbalife' front company.
DeleteVarious well-informed persons have previously complained directly to Barclays senior management in the UK about the shameful matters highlighted by this Daily Mail article. Timeless Vie (which is a satire of 'Forever Living') was created by a group of Mumsnet forum members to campaign against the 'MLM' lie. The presence of robotic 'MLM' recruiters in branches of Barclays Bank was highlighted by Mumsnet forum members years ago and detailed information about what was happening was exchanged.
The Daily Mail reporter hasn't uncovered this aspect of the 'MLM' saga without assistance.
David what's the % of distributors who make money in MLM companies?
ReplyDeleteAnonymous - In 'MLM' cultic rackets, the key information is the percentage of transient participants who have found it impossible to make an overall net-profit.
DeleteIn 'MLM' rackets, the hidden overall churn/ net-loss rates have always been effectively 100%. Since their instigation, groups like 'FLP' and 'Herbalife' have secretly churned tens of millions of individuals.
If this key information had been available to public in a comprehensible form, then no rational person would have wanted to join any so-called 'MLM Income Opportunity.'
In reality, 'MLM' has been the reality-inverting jargon camouflaging an opportunity to commit financial, social and psychological suicide.
Has Barclays been told?
DeleteAnonymous - Groups like 'FLP' and 'Herbalife' hide self-perpetuating cultic rackets which are essentially no different to that operated by the bosses of 'Scientology.' There must be some senior Barclays staff who, without being told, know that 'MLM' = cultic fraud.
DeleteI'd like to see the reaction of Barclays to someone requesting a loan to participate in a so-called 'MLM' scheme.
That said, don't forget that Barclays is a vast organisation parts of which have been involved in serious criminal activity (the LIBOR and EURIBOR scandals).