Friday, 20 March 2015

'Herbalife's (HLF)' new defender, 'CREW,' financed by George Soros 'Open Society'

More than half a century of quantifiable evidence, proves beyond all reasonable doubt that what has become popularly known as 'Network,' or 'Multi-Level, Marketing' is nothing more than an absurd, cultic, economic pseudo-science, and that the impressive-sounding made-up term 'MLM,' is, therefore, part of an extensive, thought-stopping, non-traditional jargon which has been developed, and constantly-repeated, by the instigators, and associates, of various, copy-cat, major, and minor, ongoing organized crime groups (hiding behind labyrinths of legally-registered corporate structures) to shut-down the critical, and evaluative, faculties of victims, and of casual observers, in order to perpetrate, and dissimulate, a series of blame-the-victim closed-market swindles or pyramid scams (dressed up as 'legitimate direct selling income opportunites'), and related advance-fee frauds (dressed up as 'legitimate training and motivation, self-betterment, programs, leads,' etc.).



Years before the intervention of Bill Ackman in December 2012, I was openly saying that the legally-registered, so-called 'Multi Level Marketing' company known as 'Herbalife,' has been part of an ongoing criminogenic phenomenon of historic significance.




'Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW),' claims to be a non-partisan watchdog organization that targets both Democrats and Republicans for corruption.

According to its own literature:


 'CREW is dedicated to promoting ethics and accountability in government and public life by targeting government officials—regardless of party—who sacrifice the common good to special interests.' 





Whenever I come across self-righteous individuals, and/or organizations, steadfastly pretending moral and intellectual authority (particularly, in Washington DC), one common-sense question immediately springs to mind, 'Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?' - Who will watch the watchmen?




http://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/people/george-soros

http://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2013/08/01/why-george-soros-investment-in-herbalife-is-terrible-news-for-bill-ackman/

http://crewexposed.com/who-is-crew/crews-left-wing-funders/

http://finance.yahoo.com/news/why-is-a-liberal-watchdog-group-barking-at-bill-ackman-and-fellow-short-sellers-120653340.html



Talking of persons pretending moral and intellectual authority, 'CREW' has, in fact, been heavily-financed (to the tune of $800 000) by George Soros' 'Open Society,' and that fact, casts a huge doubt on the real motives behind 'CREW's' recent, reality-inverting public intervention in the ongoing 'Herbalife' vs Bill Ackman, Wall St. saga; for at the beginning of August 2013, it was reported that the Soros Hedge Fund had bought a large stake in 'Herbalife,' causing shares in the counterfeit 'direct selling' company immediately to jump 9%; for it was also implied that the messianic billionaire, George Soros, had personally been responsible for making this trade. 


                     George Soros                                     Bill Ackman


 
          Carl Icahn


The temporary re-inflation of the market price of effectively-valueless 'Herbalife' shares, meant that (on paper) Bill Ackman was around $300 millions down on his $1.2 billion short-selling bet that 'Herbalife' is a fake enterprise which will soon be closed down, whilst (again on paper) Carl Icahn and the Soros Hedge Fund, were hundreds of millions of dollars up on their own long bet against Bill Ackman's short position.



  Paul Sohn (b.1978)

In reality, the person who was largely-responsible not only for the Soros Hedge Fund buying a significant chunk of effectively-valueless 'Herbalife' shares, but also for making sure that the rest of the world knew about it,  is Wall St. whiz -kid,  Paul Sohn. He is reported as boasting to a gathering of fellow Wall St. whiz kids (whom, for obvious reasons, he wanted to pile in on the 'Herbalife' deal) that :

'George Soros broke the Bank of England..! He can break the back of Bill Ackman!'
http://uk.businessinsider.com/paul-sohn-reportedly-left-soros-fund-2015-1?r=US

More than a year later, young Mr. Sohn was no longer employed at Soros, but the following information was made public by 'CREW:'

'As part of its longstanding interest in how Wall Street investors manipulate the regulatory process for financial gain Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) filed requests under the Freedom of Information Act with the Department of Justice, the Federal Trade Commission, and the Securities and Exchange Commission seeking documents on December 8, 2014. In light of reporting showing that hedge fund manager William Ackman orchestrated demands for investigation of Herbalife while maintaining a short position in the company’s stock, CREW’s FOIA requests with the FTC, SEC and DOJ seek to learn more about Mr. Ackman’s efforts.'



Anne Weismann accepts a Madison Award from the ALA on behalf of CREW (Photo Credit: ALA Washington Office)
Anne Weismann, Interim Executive Director of 'CREW'

http://www.citizensforethics.org/page/-/PDFs/Legal/Letters/3-18-15_Commerce_Short_Seller_Letter.pdf?nocdn=1

Completely ignoring Bill Ackman's evidence-based analysis of 'Herbalife' as the effectively-valueless corporate-front for a criminal enterprise that continues to deceive, and damage, countless vulnerable individuals around the world, Anne Weismann (Interim Executive Director of 'CREW'), has instead suddenly asked Congress to investigate attempts by short sellers 'to manipulate the federal government for personal financial gain.'
'...now it’s William Ackman ginning up a federal investigation into Herbalife to make good on a billion dollar bet against the company.'
'Mr. Ackman and his hedge fund Pershing Square Capital Management have gone to unprecedented lengths to urge federal regulatory action against Herbalife, a company in which Mr. Ackman and his fund have maintained a significant short position.'
'Mr. Ackman has admitted he just needed to get any one of the SEC, the FTC, the 50 attorney generals around the country, [or] the equivalent regulators in 87 countries, interested in investigating to succeed in driving the price down.'
According to documents obtained by 'CREW' through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, Ackman’s lawyers regularly contacted Lois Greisman, the Associate Director of the Division of Marketing Practices at the FTC, with emails attaching articles and blog posts critical of Herbalife. 
CREW says that many of these messages 'appear to have been ginned up by Ackman or his supporters.
...'While it appears DOJ and the SEC may be investigating Mr. Ackman’s conduct, Congress needs to look at this issue. Many Americans already believe Wall Street is a rigged game. Watching billionaire hedge fund managers get richer by instigating government action can only lead to further decreased confidence in the country’s financial markets and government leaders.'


Herbalife Ltd.
NYSE: HLF - Mar 20 1:24 PM EDT
40.87Price increase2.93 (7.72%)



As a result of a recent, re-intensified, coordinated propaganda campaign to paint Bill Ackman as an unethical and dishonourable criminal, the market price of effectively-valueless 'Herbalife' shares has again begun to re-inflate.

Meanwhile, back in the adult world of quantifiable reality, after examining the available data, an entirely different picture emerges. In fact, when it comes to lobbying government, the 'Herbalife' racketeers have been massively outspending Ackman, and Pershing Square, over the last two years:


Lobbying expenses of 'Herbalife' and 'Pershing Square', in US$ and % of total assets

During  2013 and 2014, 'Herbalife' committed almost 5 times as much on lobbying the US government as Ackman did. When the lobbying expenses are calculated as a percentage of total company assets, the difference  for 2013 and 2014 (respectively), is that 'Herbalife' spent 37 and 26 times as much on lobbying as Pershing Square.

Not surprisingly, 'Herbalife' has significantly increased its lobbying budget since Ackman announced his short in December 2012.

Lobbying expenses of 'Herbalife' ($) in the USA, 2009-2014
  
For many years, 'Herbalife's' annual lobbying budget remained around $500,000, but during 2012 to 2013, this figure doubled and is expected to double again during 2013 to 2014. In the first half of 2014, 'Herbalife' had already spent more than $1 million on lobbying. This was already equal to the total lobbying budget for 2013.

Lobbying expenses of 'Herbalife' as a % of annual revenues, in the USA, 2009-2014


As a percentage of annual revenue, 'Herbalife's', lobbying expenses also quadrupled during 2012 - 2014, but that is not all there is to it; for while many large commercial companies have considerable lobbying budgets, one rarely finds one that spends as much of its revenue on lobbying as 'Herbalife.'



Lobbying expenses 'Herbalife' compared to competitors, % of revenue, USA, 2012-2014

'Herbalife' steadfastly pretends to be an entirely legitimate 'direct selling enterprise' and part of the 'nutrition industry.' In which case, 'Herbalife' should consider companies like Unilever and Procter & Gamble to be its main competitors. However, these companies spend only a fraction of their revenue on lobbying compared to 'Herbalife'. As a percentage of annual turnover, 'Herbalife' has lately been spending 3 and 5 times (respectively) as much annually as P&G and Unilever. In 2014, these highly-revealing figures have climbed to an estimated 7 and 12 times (respectively).

Furthermore, 'Herbalife' mainly lobbies on issues related to 'trade and finance', whilst authentic nutrition product manufacturers, such as Unilever and P&G, focus on health related issues.

When people are asked which industries they would expect to spend the most money on lobbying? - weapons, tobacco, oil and pharmaceuticals are the most often heard replies. Few people (if any) mention the nutrition industry. Yet, by comparing the lobbying expenses of 'Herbalife' to big tobacco, oil, and pharmaceutical companies, we find a remarkable picture.


Lobbying expenses of 'Herbalife' compared to high-rollers, USA, % of revenue, 2012-2014

The increase in lobbying expenditure made by 'Herbalife' following Ackman's short, has placed this alleged'nutrition company' on pole position in comparison to weapons manufacturers, tobacco producers and oil, and pharmaceutical, companies. While during 2012 'Herbalife' only managed to outspend Royal Dutch Shell and Philip Morris (from this list), subsequently, the 'Herbalife' racketeers have put even the highest (lobbying) rollers such as Pharmaceutical giant, Pfizer, to shame. As a percentage of annual revenue, 'Herbalife' will lately spend more than twice as much on lobbying as Pfizer, 4 times as much as BAE Systems, 8 times as much as Philip Morris, and a staggering 24 times as much as Royal Dutch Shell.

The lobbying activity of 'MLM' racketeers has not been limited to the USA. Like Philip Morris, both 'Amway' and'Herbalife' have found their way to Brussels.

Not surprisingly, the lobbying activities of 'Herbalife' in the EU are slightly less shocking than in the USA. So far, Ackman's short has only made regulatory action imminent in the USA. THE 'Amway' bosses however, have committed a vast amount of stolen money to persuading EU officials to allow them to continue to thieve from the citizens of Europe - currently, almost 2 millions euros per year (and that is only what has been officially declared).





In the European Union, compared to authentic commercial companies and the highest (lobbying) rollers, both 'Herbalife' and 'Amway,' are on the lobbying pole position yet again. Although 'Herbalife' has been spending more than 5-10 times as much as Pfizer, Royal Dutch Shell, etc., on lobbying in the EU, Philip Morris did manage to spend slightly more than 'Herbalife.' However, 'Amway' massively outspent everyone. As a percentage of annual revenues (in $), the EU lobbying costs (in €) of 'Amway' are almost three times as high as those of Philip Morris, and a staggering 26 and 32 times (respectively) as much its alleged competitor, P&G, and weapons manufacturer BAE Systems.

________________________________________________________________________

NOTE:

- All total lobbying expenses for 2014 are projected (i.e. the amounts reported for the first half year were doubled).
.
- 2013 revenues were used to estimate  2014 revenues. 

- To avoid issues with exchange rate differences, the percentages for the EU were calculated using lobbying expenses in euros, and turnover in US dollars.

_______________________________________________________________________
'Citizens for Responsibilty and Ethics in Washington is dedicated to promoting ethics and accountability in government and public life by targeting government officials—regardless of party—who sacrifice the common good to special interests.' 

Presumeably, the fact that Madeleine Albright is no longer in government, explains why those tenacious watchdogs at 'CREW' don't have the slightest interest in her financial connections with racketeers.


During the last 7 years, Madeleine Albright's company , 'Albright Stonebridge Group,' has received approximately ten millions  dollars from the 'Herbalife' mob. In return for this pile of stolen cash, Ms. Albright has betrayed every single value that she (and her late father) ever claimed to have stood for, by enthusiastically participating in committing fraud and obstructing justice. 


'Herbalife's' most-useful idiot, Madeleine Albright, and her associates, can have absolutely no moral or intellectual justification for holding onto the ten millions pieces of stolen silver they have received from the bosses of the 'Herbalife' racket.







David Brear (copyright 2015)


Wednesday, 18 March 2015

California Judge rules losing-investors should have realized 'Herbalife(HLF)' shares were not safe.

More than half a century of quantifiable evidence, proves beyond all reasonable doubt that what has become popularly known as 'Network,' or 'Multi-Level, Marketing' is nothing more than an absurd, cultic, economic pseudo-science, and that the impressive-sounding made-up term 'MLM,' is, therefore, part of an extensive, thought-stopping, non-traditional jargon which has been developed, and constantly-repeated, by the instigators, and associates, of various, copy-cat, major, and minor, ongoing organized crime groups (hiding behind labyrinths of legally-registered corporate structures) to shut-down the critical, and evaluative, faculties of victims, and of casual observers, in order to perpetrate, and dissimulate, a series of blame-the-victim closed-market swindles or pyramid scams (dressed up as 'legitimate direct selling income opportunites'), and related advance-fee frauds (dressed up as 'legitimate training and motivation, self-betterment, programs, leads,' etc.).

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------




Apparently in ignorance of the above irrefutable, fully-deconstructed analysis, May 9th 2014, Pomerantz LLP announced the filing of a class action lawsuit against 'Herbalife Ltd.' and certain of its officers. The class action was filed in United States District Court, Central District of California and docketed under 2:14-cv-02850, on behalf of a class consisting of all persons or entities who purchased or otherwise acquired securities of 'Herbalife' between May 4, 2010 and April 11, 2014 both dates inclusive (the 'Class Period'). This class action sought to recover damages against 'Herbalife' and certain of its officers and directors as a result of alleged violations of the federal securities laws pursuant to Sections 10(b) and 20(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Rule 10b-5 promulgated thereunder.
In a shareholder alert document which appeared (due to its elementary grammatical errors) to have been put together by a bunch of lazy school kids, Pomerantz LLP described 'Herbalife' as:
 'a network marketing company that sells weight management, nutritional supplement and personal care products. The Company sells its products globally through a network of independent distributors, which are typically individuals with little marketing expertise that were induced by the Company to purchase the Company's products in the hope that they would be able to resell the product to other consumers or distributors. Herbalife also sells literature and promotional materials to these distributors. '
The Complaint alleged that throughout the Class Period, Defendants made materially false and misleading statements regarding the Company's business, operational and compliance policies. Specifically, Defendants made false and/or misleading statements and/or failed to disclose that: (i) the Company's operations were based on a pyramid scheme whereby its distributors generate revenue by recruiting other distributors rather than selling 'Herbalife's' diet and nutritional products to the general public; (ii) the Company engaged in deceptive trade practices where it unduly pressured its members to purchase more products to resell as one of its 'distributors'; and (iii) as a result of the above, the Company's financial statements were materially false and misleading at all relevant times.

The complaint put forward no original research or fully-deconstructed analysis; instead it relied on the jargon-laced facts that:

On December 19th 2012, CNBC reported that Bill Ackman, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of Pershing Square Capital Management, L.P. considers 'Herbalife' to be a pyramid scheme after spending a year researching the Company's fundamentals.  On this news, 'Herbalife' stock declined $5.16 per share, or over 12%, to close at $37.34 per share on December 19, 2012.
On December 20, 2012, Ackman conducted a presentation concerning 'Herbalife' at the Sohn Investment Conference where he affirmed his conclusion that 'Herbalife' is a pyramid scheme as its 'distributors' make more money by recruiting other 'distributors' than selling the Company's products to the general public.  Specifically, Ackman alleged that since the founding of the Company, approximately 1.9 million 'distributors' have failed to make any money from selling 'Herbalife' products, costing them a net loss of $3.8 billion.  On this news, 'Herbalife' stock declined an additional $10.07 per share, or over 27%, over the next two trading sessions, to close at $27.27 per share on December 21, 2012.
On January 9, 2013, the New York Times reported that the Securities and Exchange Commission had opened an investigation into the Company. 
On January 23, 2014, U.S. Senator Edward J. Markey of Massachusetts sent letters to federal regulators, including the SEC and the FTC, urging them to investigate 'Herbalife.' Mr. Markey also sent a letter to 'Herbalife's' CEO, Michael O. Johnson, asking several questions about the company's 'business,' including pointed requests that reflected the concerns raised by Ackman  in December 2012. Some of the questions asked in the letter to 'Herbalife' include: (1) "How much profit (net earnings after expenses) can the average 'distributor' expect to make from retailing to non-'distributors' (i.e., people who are not directly involved in 'Herbalife' themselves)?"; and (2) "What's the correct number of sales outside the network as a percentage of total sales" for each of the last five years and information on these sales measured by product, quantity and dollars. 
Senator Markey urged both the FTC and SEC to examine whether 'Herbalife was a legitimate multilevel marketing Company,' whose revenues are ultimately generated by sales to the general public; or whether 'Herbalife' was a pyramid scheme, whose revenues were dependent on continuous recruitment of other 'distributors,' which were ultimately left sustaining substantial losses on their purchases of the Company's weight loss products.  To highlight evidence that 'Herbalife' may indeed operate as a pyramid scheme, Senator Markey pointed to instances where residents of Massachusetts suffered crushing financial setbacks as a result of the Company's marketing practices.   On this news, 'Herbalife' stock declined $7.61 per share, or over 10%, to close at $65.92 per share on January 23, 2014.
On April 11, 2014, the Financial Times reported that the United States Department of Justice and Federal Bureau of Investigation had opened a criminal probe of 'Herbalife.'  On this news, shares of 'Herbalife' spiraled downward from $59.84 to $51.48, more than 13%. 
________________________________________________________________________



Dale Fischer District Judge.jpg
Judge Fischer

California federal judge, Dale Susan Fischer, has now dismissed this short-sighted shareholder class-action suit, arguing that 

'there was no evidence the ('Herbalife') company had made disclosures to investors that caused its shares to fall.'

Judge Fischer rejected the plaintiffs' argument that the Dec. 2012 presentation from Bill Ackman's Pershing Square Capital calling 'Herbalife' a pyramid scheme was a corrective disclosure.

 'The [amended complaint] and plaintiffs’ related arguments are insufficient to compel the conclusion that the Pershing presentation was based on previously unavailable information or that the information could not be understood absent of expert analysis.'

______________________________________________________________________



Reuters subsequently reported  - Herbalife Ltd (HLF) won the dismissal of a lawsuit that claimed the maker of weight-loss and nutritional products fraudulently portrayed itself as a legitimate company, and that shareholders lost money because it was actually an illegal pyramid scheme.
U.S. District Judge Dale Fischer in Los Angeles said that shareholders led by two pension funds did not show that questions raised about Herbalife's business by hedge fund manager William Ackman and various investigators showed that the company had fraudulently inflated its stock price.

Ackman and his Pershing Square Capital Management LP have campaigned against Herbalife since December 2012, when they revealed a $1 billion bet against the Los Angeles-based company. Herbalife has long denied it is a pyramid scheme.

Herbalife shares were up 9.4 percent at $37.68 on Wednesday afternoon after rising as much as 14 percent earlier in the session. They remain well below their January 2014 peak above $83.

Fischer on Monday rejected claims in the proposed class action that news about concerns from Massachusetts Senator Edward Markey, a Federal Trade Commission probe, weak quarterly results, and even questions raised by Ackman and hedge fund manager David Einhorn were "corrective disclosures" that revealed Herbalife's fraud.

"Just as black swans may exist, there may theoretically be some form of opinion that is factual or revelatory in nature such that it qualifies as a corrective disclosure," Fischer wrote in a footnote. "Such an opinion would need to reveal to the market something previously hidden or actively concealed. That is not this case."

The lead plaintiffs are the Oklahoma Firefighters Pension and Retirement System and the City of Atlanta Firefighters’ Pension Fund. Their lawyer, Maya Saxena, on Wednesday said the plaintiffs are considering whether to amend their complaint.
Herbalife said it welcomed Fischer's decision.

"We are confident in the strong fundamentals of our business model and remain committed to helping people and communities improve their nutrition," it said.
Critics have said Herbalife misleads distributors about how much they can earn, and that its success depends more on recruiting distributors than selling products.

Ackman told CNBC last week that federal investigators examining possible manipulation of Herbalife's stock price have subpoenaed people hired by a consulting group working for Pershing.

Another federal judge in Los Angeles will on May 11 consider final approval of Herbalife's $15 million settlement with distributors who said the company misled them.

The case is In re: Herbalife Ltd Securities Litigation, U.S. District Court, Central District of California, No. 14-02850.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Based on the limited complaint with which she was presented, Judge Fischer was not able to recognize 'Herbalife' as being one part of an ongoing criminogenic phenomenon of historic significance. Contrary to how the 'Herbalife' Ministry of Truth has attempted to spin this news, when translated into to plain English, Judge Fischer has not ruled that Bill Ackman's analysis of 'Herbalife' as the legally-registered corporate-front for a criminal enterprise, was inaccurate. She has evidently ruled that, in her opinion, anyone (including advisers to pension funds) who was so reckless as to have bought 'Herbalife' shares between May 4th 2010 and April 11th 2014, only has themselves to blame, because Bill Ackman's analysis proved that there was sufficient information publicly available in order for anyone to apply common-sense and deduce that 'Herbalife' shares were probably not a wise investment.


David Brear (copyright 2015)


Monday, 16 March 2015

'Herbalife' propaganda paints Bill Ackman as unethical and dishonorable.


Bill Ackman says 'Herbalife' is effectively-valueless, because it is a 'criminal enterprise.'

The bosses of the 'Herbalife' racket have been bluffing and on December 20th, 2012, hedge fund manager, Bill Ackman, called their bluff by revealing he was holding a vast short-selling position involving around $1.2 billions of 'Herbalife'  shares. However, at the same time Bill Ackman laid his own winning-hand on the table (by publishing a detailed analysis of why he considers the legally-registered corporate structure known as 'Herbalife' to be the front for a vast and damaging pyramid fraud and, therefore, effectively-valueless), he also declared that all the profits he will personally make from this tainted deal will be handed over to charity.  


'Herbalife' racketeer, Michael Johnson.

Later in December 2012, Michael Johnson refused to lay his own losing hand on the table. Instead, he grinned and insisted that 'Herbalife has millions and millions of customers,' and that Bill Ackman's analysis was based on his not understanding that many 'Herbalife customers' are 'distributors.' Michael Johnson then insisted that 90% of all 'Herbalife's' declared sales were to persons outside of the company's own distribution network. In reality, for more than 30 years, the overwhelming majority of all 'Herbalife's' declared 'sales' have been economically-incestuous internal transactions between the company and persons under temporary take it or leave it contract to the company, and who were clearly defined as 'Distributors,' but who have lately been redefined as 'Members.' Soon afterwards, Michael Johnson claimed that he had 'mispoke.'

The laughable, but predictable, reaction of 'Herbalife' boss, Michael Johnson, was to continue his bluff, by steadfastly pretending innocence whilst accusing Bill Ackman of wilful market manipulation, i.e. lying in order to damage a valuable American enterprise and make money. Yet neither Michael Johnson, nor his previously-aggressive echelon of attorneys, have been able to refute Bill Ackman's published analysis of 'Herbalife' by providing quantifiable evidence which would prove that the so-called 'Herbalife MLM income opportunity' has generated any significant, and sustainable, revenue other than that deriving unlawfully from a never-ending chain of losing investors around the world. This is because, for decades, the bosses of  the 'Herbalife' racket have been riding on the coat tails of the 'Amway' racketeers - operating a dissimulated closed-market swindle (right under the noses of regulators and financial journalists), in which they have been laundering billions of dollars of unlawful, losing investments (based on the false expectation of future reward), by falsely-declaring these payments as lawful sales (based on value and demand).




Sometimes, when looking at cults, you need to pinch yourself, to make sure that you are not dreaming.


As a result of inside information which was apparently first touted (but without any takers) by a PR specialist working for the 'Herbalife' mob, to various mainstream media publications, the 'Wall St. Journal' reported last week that US law enforcement agents have launched a probe to determine whether short seller, Bill Ackman, has been engaging (via paid third parties - activists lobbyists, consultants, etc.) in unlawful market manipulation, to drive down the price of 'Herbalife' shares.

(Bear in mind that core 'Herbalife' adherents have been programmed to believe that Bill Ackman is a ruthless Wall St. Shark who has invented a pack of lies about 'Herbalife' simply to make money). 


Within hours, this carefully-constructed, black propaganda story was all over the mainstream financial media, but it had become qualified as the Office of the Mahattan US Attorney, and FBI agents, checking the voracity of complaints filed by a few alleged 'Herbalife' victims who had been traced by sub-contractors working for 'Global Strategy Group' (a reputable consultancy firm working for Bill Ackman's Pershing Square Capital).


As a result of this latest reality-inverting chapter of the 'MLM income opportunity' fairy story, the market price of effectively-valueless 'Herbalife' shares, rose by more than 8%.


Typically, when this two-dimensional mixture of lies and truths had already gone around the world, the multi-dimensional truth was still getting its boots on.







David Brear (copyright 2015)







Probe of Ackman Team Over Herbalife Campaign May Go Nowhere: Legal Experts

U.S. authorities investigating potential manipulation of Herbalife Ltd.'s shares by consultants working for billionaire investor William Ackman will find it difficult to prove that false statements were deliberately made to drive down the company's value, securities lawyers said.


In a probe that began last year, the FBI and the office of Manhattan U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara have been examining whether the consultants solicited people to file baseless complaints with regulators regarding Herbalife, two people familiar with the matter said. There is no indication that Ackman himself is a target of the investigation.

News of the probe has thrown a temporary shadow over the more than two-year campaign by Ackman and his hedge fund Pershing Square Capital Management against Herbalife. Ackman alleges that Herbalife is a pyramid scheme and he has taken a $1 billion short bet that its stock price will slide. The nutritional supplements seller has long denied the allegations, saying the campaign is based on misinformation.

U.S. law defines market manipulation as artificially raising or depressing the price of a security for the purpose of inducing trades by others. Potential methods include orchestrating phantom trades or spreading false information.

In the most common type of market manipulation, someone buys or shorts a stock, spreads misinformation about it to drive its price up or down sharply, and then reverses their position to take a profit. The scheme, commonly known as a "pump and dump" or "buy, lie and sell high" scheme, depends on the manipulator reversing their position before those being deceived catch on to what is happening.
However, lawyers with expertise in securities law say that the Ackman campaign has not attempted to hide what it is doing and has argued its stance very publicly. Ackman has also pledged to retain his short position in the stock until Herbalife is exposed as a pyramid scheme and its stock goes to zero.

"For me, it's impossible to imagine that Ackman is involved," said Jonathan Macey, a Yale University professor who has made public comments in defense of the tactics of short sellers, including Ackman. "If he had made up some lie about the company, he hasn't profited from that, because he's still short. In manipulation, at some point you've got to transact the security. Otherwise, there's no point to it."

Herbalife stock rose 8.2 percent on Friday because of news of the probe. The Wall Street Journal was first to report the existence of the investigation after hours on Thursday.

Spokesmen for both the FBI and the Manhattan U.S. Attorney's office declined to comment.

It was not clear on Friday whether the investigation had focused on particular individuals, or whether any wrongdoing had been discovered. One of the sources said it could end without any charges being filed.


RECEIVED SUBPOENAS

In a statement on Thursday night, Herbalife spokesman Alan Hoffman said that Ackman's bet meant he had a direct financial interest in hurting Herbalife and had orchestrated a false and fabricated attack against the company. "We are confident in the strong fundamentals of our business model," he said.
On Friday, Herbalife declined to respond to questions.

Ackman says he believes Herbalife is a company that is based on signing up more distributors and getting them to buy its products, rather than on meeting the needs of consumers, and that as markets become saturated with new distributors the business is doomed to fail.

Ackman told CNBC on Friday that some people who had done work for one consulting firm he was using, Global Strategy Group, had received subpoenas. He said that the firm had hired some subcontractors around the country.

He later told Reuters in an interview that his firm was still working with Global Strategy. "We work with the best of the best. We can afford to. My belief is they conduct themselves appropriately," he said.

A Global Strategy spokesman said in a statement: "It is our clear understanding that neither the firm nor any of our employees are a target of any investigation, and we are confident that all our work surpasses the highest legal and ethical standards."

Market manipulation prosecutions generally require proving intent to lie or deceive, which is difficult without an incriminating document, securities lawyers said.

"You're always dealing with circumstantial evidence. We don't have the ability to probe people's minds," said Eric Chaffee, a University of Toledo law professor.

Ackman said Pershing Square's very public campaign was the furthest thing from market manipulation.

"What have we done? We've shorted the stock. We've disclosed the size of our position. We've made a 330-page PowerPoint presentation," he told Reuters. "Market manipulators don't make 330-page PowerPoint presentations and broadcast them globally."
Emphasizing the public nature of his campaign, he added, "No one could say anything worse about a company that what we've said about Herbalife. It's a pyramid scheme. It's a criminal enterprise that harms poor people."

U.S. guarantees of free speech mean that short-sellers have a right to talk down a stock price, even with the assistance of public relations and lobbying firms like the ones Ackman has hired.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission often brings civil charges against the manipulators of penny stocks, which are most vulnerable to misinformation. Enforcement cases are much more rare among big, listed companies.

"Prosecutions of market manipulation by the government are as scarce as hen's teeth," said James Cox, a Duke University law professor.


© 2015 Thomson/Reuters. All rights reserved.